Tag: return to play

  • Relationships with Athletic Trainers

    There’s a unique situation that happens in the modern world at the high school level of Athletics that I think a little bit of discussion would dramatically help with:

     Your kids and how they deal with the athletic trainer at their school.

    And by your kids I mean; your kids, you, the doctor or PT you use, and how you handle the entire episode.

     As the guy that based his entire professional career on his relationships with some fantastic athletic trainers and sports docs he met during my sports career, I can’t stress to you enough the importance of building a good relationship with your athletic trainer.

    As college athletes, Nikki and I LOVED our athletic trainers.  We wanted their job.   That is of course until we saw what their job entailed.   Then we wanted a similar job with the same direction and protocols but done in a different way.   Damn, those Athletic trainers work!   Hard.

    So This goes for you as an athlete but also as a parent.

    Even if you aren’t on a first-name basis with your athletic trainer, know this.   These guys/girls are here to go to bat for your kid in a time of need. They are there for protection, treatment, workups, and as a first line of treatment in an emergency.   This year more than at any other time in history, it has been shown that ATs make a difference.  They save lives, speed recovery, win super bowls, change protocols and care.    They care man!

    They aren’t out to make your kid sit on the bench and miss playing time.

    We are in a very fantastic time in history – safer, healthier, more access to entertainment, less starvation and poverty worldwide, medical care is accessible – even at the high school level, most districts have an Athletic trainer right there on staff, typically at each game and with a full functioning clinic just down the hall from the locker room.

    It is a fantastic first line of sports medicine care. 

    Having that doesn’t always make for perfection, however.

    Some nuances are quite distracting and tough and make easy to go to “right answers” tough.

    This article is not an attempt to fix all problems in all cases because that’s what I feel is a massive problem in the world.  Each case is different. Oh, they aren’t all unique per se – Do this work for a decade, and you’ll start to pick up on trends, see a lot of repeats, and get a system.   I certainly hope so.  Every profession should get more efficient and better at categorizing as they get more experience. Athletic trainers, coaches, administrators, sports-based chiropractors, orthopedic surgeons, and everyone in the sports medicine universe should be able to come up with a Direction within the first minute of evaluating and watching an athlete and injury.  That’s common sense.

     Let me dive just a little bit deeper.

     As a sports-based chiropractor, I interact with athletic trainers from all sorts of different districts with different policies and different personalities daily    I have my favorites. I have the ones that are easier to work with. But I also have the ones that take a specific response and reaction, and I am constantly evolving the way that I handle each and every one of these relationships.

    Being stubborn and just stating in stone: “I’m going to handle them all the same way.” is not only being selfish and nonpliable but is a sure way to get many things wrong.

     Just like every profession, the interaction between athletic trainers, coaches, and anyone in the sports medicine team needs to be individualized and personalized.   That’s true with the athletes, parents, radiologists, PT’s and orthos as well, It’s about relationships.

     So I’m going to give you a scenario that I go through nearly daily.

     Where you fit in on the Spectrum is entirely a matter of perspective.

     An athletic trainer with specific guidelines and protocols and legal liability needs that have to be followed will have a different perspective than the mom who just wants her kid to play in the game on Friday. The doctor, pediatrician, chiro, or PT in the loop will have another, and let’s not downplay reality.   The athlete, who by far and away is the most critical person in this equation, will have a different perspective that may change hour by hour based on ideas such as pain, the opportunity for play, team, drive, stubbornness, fear, as well as a million other emotions and thoughts that are in fluctuation faster in adolescents than we can even remember or comprehend.

    In nearly every article I write, I talk about AWARENESS and how important it is. How we function in all aspects of life based on our awareness. A different perspective gives us better awareness and lets us make better decisions.

    As much as I would love to have some discussion and would love to see some chats after one of my articles – just take a second to think it through from at least three perspectives before you write in the comments section.  THEN….please write.   I’d love to scenario strategize.

    Let me set up a few scenarios as I feel Learning happens quicker with examples.

    A high school track athlete goes to their athletic trainer with low grade back pain after a basketball practice.

    “My back hurts.”

    The athletic trainer states:  

    “We have a policy at this school. If your back hurts, understand that you are at the age that a stress fracture at the lower lumbar is a fairly frequent problem. You need to sit out until you have been evaluated by an orthopedic surgeon or someone that can sign off on a form saying that you do not have that issue.”

    The kid is out of sports from that second on. That stinks. But it can happen. It does, and at some schools, that is THE actual protocol. For damn near every issue.

     The reality is:

    That’s a fair protocol. Nothing the athletic trainer said is incorrect.   However, there was no exam or evaluation. In a case like this, there’s a strong possibility that if one minute would have been utilized to better evaluate an athlete, I think a better decision could have been arrived at quicker.    Athletic trainers are well-trained and have mountains of experience with low back pain in athletics. They can and do judge and are way better at this kind of decision than anyone gives them credit for. So when I hear this, I cringe. “C’mon man, make a better decision!”

    Contrastingly,  as someone that does this for a living daily and has two decades of experience, I can almost guarantee you,  examination and evaluation questions such as “Show me where it hurts, Grade the pain on a scale of 1 to 10,  can you bend over?” Arent sufficient enough to truly make a good call as to the athletes state of being.

     So what’s the right answer?    Every single kid that has back pain needs an MRI?

    The truth is MRI isn’t even the right call for MOST back pain. It’s used. It’s looked at as THE ANSWER. But it’s just not. It can show some things that we cant evaluate but it’s simply a picture, much is lost as a picture doesn’t show MOST.

    The reality is that MRI probably takes two to three weeks to even set up.    They are expensive.    It’s most likely Overkill as nearly every single athlete has back pain at some time anyway and even could lead you down the wrong path. Its needed and I use is multiple times per week. But for every case? Even if it was free and took seconds…No. It’s not the only factor in proper decision making.

     Like I said, it’s a case-by-case issue. 

    The honest reality is that a complete examination, evaluation, and treatment may allow us to decide on a treatment protocol that might show some results.    We can then use these ideas to make better decisions but only after seeing if the athlete has responded to our care. I say daily, “We’ll know a lot more after seeing how this guy responds to the treatment.””

     Just like the MRI may be overkill, sending that kid to a chiropractor or physical therapist who demands 16 sessions and four weeks of therapy before returning them to Competition damn near cuts off their entire season.    Most likely, it is overkill.    Unneeded. 

     Yet there is always the potential that something more serious is going on and as a parent, coach, coach, AT, or doctor we want to make sure that we can discover any issues as early as we can to protect the athlete and maximize their return.

     That’s why policies are in place.   Bureaucracy.   Better ideas -only, a slower timeline.

     This is why I have no hair.

     Because in the everyday situation I explained above, the reality is this:   If this “referral cascade” happens repeatedly in an athletic training situation in high school, parents, athletes and coaches will often start to avoid the AT.   

     Every day I get a call from an athlete who has an issue that has not seen the athletic trainer and the parents directly ask me not to speak with the athletic trainer on this case.   Even though by working together, we can maximize the recovery time and the safety for the athlete, they want to have their kid to be seen “out of the loop.”  Typically in an effort to speed their return to play.

    Now let me add some more reality.

    In the case above, the athlete who has hurt her back and goes the athletic trainer.

    What changes if the report that the athlete gives the athletic trainer sounds like this, “ Hey doc, I hurt my back. Can you look at it?”

    AT:   Of course, How long have you had the issue?

    Athlete:   On and off for about a year and a half.

    BANG!

    Honestly, nothing has changed. Same idea but stated with one nuance.

    If this athlete is a junior in high school, more than likely, during the course of Athletics, she has had back pain on and off for a year and a half.    It may not be severe, most likely it is nothing, but the terminology alone almost demands that the athletic trainer takes a different look at the injury. That statement, “on and off for a year and a half” demands a better look.    Even if it is nothing more than tight muscles that come and go with the tossing and turning of being a teenager, staying up till midnight studying for exams, and then playing football games. Nothing has changed other than the way it is reported.

    This is where the reality and the difficulty of the situation comes from.

    These are real-life things and real-life situations that I see every day.    The parents call or text and ask, “Can you give me a release so my kid can do Sports?”

    I want to. Most of the time if they have my personal cell, they are friends of my kids. i probably coached them in sports and know that they are just sore from doing 3×5 squats heavy on Wednesday. But, there is liability. What if it is something serious this time? What if I sign the form or call the AST and tell them they’re good to go and the kid cant move by that afternoon? Do you think that if a kid told me they had on and off pain for a year and a half that I would just sign a form releasing them that day?

    Because of the way it was reported and the way it was stated, Everything Has Changed.

    Just take a minute to think About how this changes the athletic trainer’s perspective and the doctor that now needs to sign off on the state of the athlete.

    Because there’s another reality in this relationship.

     Despite being very good at sports medicine and doing a lot of discussions, treatments, muscle work, exercise protocols, and just overall great Sports Medicine.   The perspective the athlete often has is this:   “ The chiropractor popped my bones/ the athletic trainer put stim and ice on me.”

    Trust me when I tell you, that’s not what is going on.

     I can go on with a million examples, but that’s not what this article is.   Before I leave, I want to just add a couple caveats.

     What happens when the athlete reports to the athletic trainer?

    “ I heard a pop in my knee.”

    “ I landed on my head and now I feel dizzy”

    “Don’t worry doc, it’s nothing,  Can you just stretch out my back?”

    “Is there a tape job you can do for my ankle?”

    As a parent, I want my athletic trainers, nurses, orthos, coaches, strength trainers and everyone involved to just give a damn.   

    But my perspective and what is said make a difference.

    As we reach the end of this article, that seriously could go on for an entire morning lecture at a conference (hint:I’m available for presentations!) please get the point:

    It’s about how we react and teach our kids to talk to those around them that make a difference.

    And it’s 100x more critical now as text messages, despite being so much more convenient AND being the primary mode of communication between everyone, lack the significant handicap of being unable to inflect tone.  So “It really hurts” doesn’t mean much via text. Or it could mean something serious.

    “I heard a pop in my knee while landing in hurdles.” – as a text can be read a dozen different ways.    This is the impossible situation Athletic trainers, as well as the rest of us find ourselves in more and more frequently each day.   

    Honestly, as I write this article, it is 10 am.   I have had 4 text messages from friends/clients showing different body parts.    Ex.  a picture of an elbow with a finger pointing at it. “Hey doc: Elbow pain; what should I do?”

    Understand the importance of this.   It’s impossible.   Teach your kids to communicate better with athletic trainers.  Understand liability, bureaucracy yet at the same time realize they want the best for your young athlete.

    The days of, “Just stick them in there, we need a first down.” have been gone for a long time.   Nobody does this anymore. At any time.

    Nobody:  No coach, no athletic trainer, no booster wants a kid that is injured, to play.  It’s not worth it.   But we have to filter out some level of pain that is inherent in sports and practice and decipher from severe injury and the reality is, “IT DEPENDS”

    The truth is, as a sports med team, the best approach is nearly always, “Here is what I feel is going on, lets proceed this way and really evaluate what we deemed was the best approach.  Is the athlete responding as expected?   Is it worse?  Should we change our approach?”

    If you are even a little interested in this article I’d strongly urge you to look at one entitled “Return to Play.” as a great model for recovery as the idea of “rest 4-6 weeks and then try to come back and play” is perhaps THE WORST recovery mode, yet often the most prescribed from a clinic.

    As a parent, don’t forget that the ATs and coaches are there daily.  They are much better equipped to evaluate your athlete’s recovery and ability than a clinician in an office despite the 6 degrees hanging on their wall.   There is no way to replicate movement, change of direction, balance, acceleration, speed, or mechanics in a clinic despite all of our best tools.   The BEST way is the professional athletics way, where all of these guys are out there at the exact same time and have worked together for years, so communication happens at a near-telepathic level – but that’s not a reality for the majority of us.  It’s not possible – so we have the next best thing.   Your athlete is getting that.  

    Or I certainly hope they are.  Just like every career, some are over worked, lazy, burned out, thinking about their personal lives and their own finances and marriage and their own kids.    There is real life all around every person you meet – but for the most part – we’re all trying our best – athletic trainers and sports docs included.   

    Get that perspective.

    Teach your kids to communicate better.

    Understand logistics and reality.

    Be mindful that we all want the best for your kid.

    And be cognizant that your particular case, despite being your kid, the most critical person in the world, is most likely not unique nor even uncommon and that we have the experience to handle this in what we believe is the best outcomes. Oh yeah, and in line right behind you are ten more kids with a similar situation.

    We’re all doing our best in a dynamic, stressful, emotional situation that we know we signed up for because we love doing it. It’s our job. It’s our passion. But sometimes, it takes a bit of time and decision-making. Better communication is a critical step that happens on your athlete’s end. “It just hurts” is a time waster and a slow process.

    SportsDocDc is Dr. Chad Peters DC. A sports-based chiropractor focusing on sports performance and recovery for athletes. He works hand in hand with some of the best athletic trainers, PTs, orthos, and radiologists in the area. He is always striving to make the treatments, flow, and protocols more closely aligned with what is happening a the professional level.

  • Return to Play Criteria for AT’s and Coaches

    Return to Play Criteria for AT’s and Coaches

    athletefootballonbench

    There is an issue that we have been seeing with Return to Play after Injury in high school aged athletes.   It’s a small issue, more bureaucracy – not actual treatment issue.  It’s the problem of athletes/patients seeking treatment outside of the school.

    I have presented this idea at high school in-services and have had good feedback and great implementation of plan improvement with a minimal effort and next to no expense.

    My proposed idea gets the athletes, coaches, athletic trainer and ancillary staff on the same page and makes discussion of injury much more thorough with a huge addition of information. This, in my opinion, allows for better treatment of injured athletes, better compliance from the athlete and an improved ability to evaluate progress while returning from an injury.

    The problem lies in, if a patient is seeing another doctor, outside of the athletic trainer’s room, the buck passes to the MD, Pediatrician, chiropractor, PT etc rather the the athletic trainer to make treatment, rehab and return to play recommendations.

    While this may seem like a great idea for administration and liability issues, it creates room for problems.

    Although I think the diagnosis and occasionally rehab/treatment for some athletic injuries and definitely for illnesses can best be managed by an adjunct doctor, the athletic trainer in conjunction with coaches is best suited to assess the athlete’s day to day recovery and return to play and practice.

    The doctor is hampered in this regard as we just don’t get to monitor day to day function and have to rely on standard and structured testing to secure our diagnosis.  Our job, as ancillary staff, is in the diagnosis. Further xrays, testing, recommendations for surgery, ruling in/out major illness etc is our job and where our expertise is best utilized.

    How long a basic sport injury keeps an athlete out of activity is not our strong suit.  

    In this article I will explain this idea in more depth with a proposed idea on how to implement a BASIC but possibly improved “return to play criteria” for your athletes.

    Let’s use an ankle sprain, in a high school track athlete, as an example.

    A junior in high school 400 m track athlete sprains her ankle while playing pick up basketball one day after practice.   

    Because the injury happened “after hours” – the parents take her to a minor ER clinic just down the road from their house.

    The doctor makes the easy diagnosis of a grade 1 to 2 ankle sprain and recommends rest, ice, compression and elevation.  Common Injury, Standard treatment.

    The athlete then gets a note for time away from activity as it’s needed for the sports participation/ athletics period etc. as well as a courtesy for the coaches and training staff.

    In some instances, this athlete may not even be able to receive additional treatment from the Athletic trainer due to the issue happening outside of the school.  That’s a shame. Most of the athletic trainers I know would still treat the athlete… however their hands may be tied due to policy.

    Before this athlete can return to play and practice, the MD that saw her must sign a note for release.   

    Typically, the parents call the clinic and say, “Can I get a note for my kid to get back to competition?”    

    That’s a fair enough request and this is how the system works on paper.  It seems uncomplicated and proper policy. The MD wrote the note and decided, based on their expertise, the treatment plan.

    And here is where the bureaucracy train starts the locomotive of inadequacy.

    The doctor, in all good conscious, cannot sign a letter for return to play or practice without first running the athlete through a set of tests again to see if the ligaments are in fact strong enough, as in enough healing has occurred, to allow for resistance and activity.  To protect the athlete from further injury.

    1. Is there a set standard – what should be done?  This is in a clinic remember, not on the field of play – this is at the doctor’s office and even this is assuming the same doctor is in the same stand alone minor ER setting.  It could be weeks before the athlete’s and doctor’s schedules even match up. Anyway, what should the doctor do in this situation?

    Just call it in?  Have the receptionist just write a note after the suggested time frame?  That’s poor doctoring, I don’t think you’ll get much of that anymore…so what else?   Feel it? Have the athlete stand on it? Run up and down the hallway a time or two? Or more commonly – just go by the standard 6 weeks! rest and no activity.   I mean, that’s safe right?   (NOTE: recovery for this injury should not take 6 weeks.)

    1. Is this doctor even qualified to make these decisions?   A license as a chiropractor, MD, DO, dentist, PA, NP etc don’t necessarily make you expert level at sports injuries.  Diagnoses? Yes. Treatments and Return to Play, not necessarily. That kind of stuff takes experience even if you did have a sports specialization – which most don’t have – not to the degree an Athletic Trainer does.
    2. Even if the athlete looks strong through the clinical exam and testing – Does that correlate well with the sports field, the track and the court?  The demands are completely different and maximal ‘game play’ exertion is unobtainable in the clinical setting.

    So let’s assume this athlete waited 6 weeks for the ankle sprain and then has been cleared medically…ahhh finally.  Well half the season has passed and now the athlete has not only been deconditioned and is behind the curve competitively but I would make a strong argument that 6 weeks of rest has in fact, not helped the sprain heal well but mostly just decreased pain.   The initial sprain has need of a progressive resistance return and strengthening program and usually sooner rather than later.

    Stated differently-  Rest may have in fact, weakened the entire joint complex at the expense of rest and pain control.    

    Again, the most qualified person to perform these treatments and exercises are an athletic trainer although I’ll allow the argument of a sports based physical therapist/ rehab specialist such as some chiropractors and even personal trainers work as.   There are qualified people, I’m just suggesting, most athletes at the middle school/high school level arent getting this.

    Communication is the key to any and all patient recovery.  It speeds up everything. But let’s not forget reality.    This isn’t the NFL and there is not an infinite resource of trained staff and doctors and athletic trainer in a one on one setting out in the field.    The athletic trainer ratio to athlete is not 1 to 1. More like 1 to 150, especially in the high school setting.

    The athlete needs help – the Athletic Trainers need help too!

    Using coaches in decision making.

    Coaches are the ones out there.  Despite not having as extensive of background to make complex medical decisions, they intimately understand body mechanics, gait, pain levels, wimpiness as well as just “knowing their athlete.”

    Coaches can tell how hard to push an athlete and any ethical coach will not want to push an athlete too far.   They need that competitor on their team!

    Coaches and Athletic trainers have much more immediate communication with both the athlete and the injury.   The athletic trainer with coaches input ARE THE BEST at the evaluation of the injury itself with regard to recovery.

    Is the athlete going to make themselves worse?   Do they need further consultation? Are they OK to move?

    Ancillary staff – chiropractors, PT’s, pediatricians, team doc, surgeons etc can work one on one to help mitigate serious risk and allow for more direct work in a one on one setting and help get through the injury itself.

    Again, my argument is that the ancillary staff is not qualified for return to play criteria.    We aren’t on the field and don’t get to see the athlete in movement and sports specific situation.

    Athletic trainers and coaches are together, the best qualified and should work together with input from the athlete on any and all return to play.

    If “passing the buck” to ancillary medical staff, plan on a generic 6 weeks rest.

    Basic return to play criteria

    Use “pennies”

    In the upper level sports teams..college and professional – the use of different colored jerseys or “pennies” are extremely common.

    These pennies allow for immediate recognition to the coaches and staff both in live practice and video that the athlete is not 100%.

    They allow for the athlete to still be present, play in correct positions, see in-play decision making for game day corrections, have movement and be participating with the team.

    Teammates can easily recognize the injured athlete is not 100% – so contact, speed etc should be appropriately controlled so as to allow for recovery.

    Coaches can evaluate practices with the understanding that the athlete is understanding week by week adjustments and is engaged mentally with the ability to digest that the athlete may not be fully functional in practice but with the understanding that by game day they may.    Reps, even at a reduced speed,contact and ability is infinitely better than no reps and I think in 2019 everyone can agree rest alone is almost never the best recovery option.

    My suggestion:  use pennies in nearly every practice.  Get the athlete on the field.

    I utilize a 6 day recovery to 100% model for low grade injuries.

    Day 1 : 50%

    Day 2 : 65%

    Day 3 : 75%

    Day 4 : 85%

    Day 5 : 95%

    Day 6 :100%

    The athlete can not go past his assigned percentage for each day.   

    If the athlete passes the day with no setbacks or recurrences he is moved up the chart to the next percentage.

    If there is a re exacerbation, the athlete stays at the same percentage for the following day or a reduction in percentage based on the Athletic Trainer’s and coach’s discretion.   

    Further therapies, rehab techniques, clinical work etc is done IN ADDITION to practice, not in substitution of.    

    Certain max ability drills such as sprints, gassers, max out weight room workouts etc are not done until the athlete can tolerate them.     The additional therapies required for maximal recovery may work into these time slots.

    By game day, the AT and the coach will have a good “working idea” of the athlete’s ability and chance of exacerbation and re-injury.

    The reality is in all sports, the athlete may not be 100% in each case.   I’m not suggesting 100% before competition as I think that’s another “on paper” reality that isn’t a realistic in the sports world.  By 6 games in to a typical high school football season, I would argue, no one is 100%. I bring this up because I had conversation with an athletic trainer that didn’t want his athlete’s seeking out my care as a sports based chiropractor because he had a policy of “100% healthy or No Play.”   This meant that if they were seeing me for a pre-game “tune-up” , it equated to being injured and he threatened to sit athletes out of competition that week.

    The reality of this is that athletes rarely would seek out treatment form the athletic trainer for fear of being benched for little tweaks or tight muscles.   They knew that if they had any reported “complaints” it was viewed as injury.

    This is a double kill situation where the athletic trainer saw very few athletes.  He could go about his day blissfully unaware of basic, simple care his teams would benefit from – completely confident that his teams were perfect with no complaints.  The actuality was no one dared seek their team’s “professional.” The coaches wouldn’t use him as they knew he would sideline their players, the parents used outside staff exclusively for the same idea and the athlete’s themselves had no confidence or even worse were scared to talk to the athletic trainer about injury or sports performance.  The best qualified member of the staff was “out of the loop.”

    Back to return to play…

    The alternative to doing what I feel is correct, is rest.  Wait for a release from a doctor that doesn’t have any way to make a decision other than allotted time, and I feel, a significant chance of reinjury, as the athlete has had no ability to re adapt and prepare for the demands of competition.

    I understand there needs to be policy.  I understand that policy at certain districts are at odds to my proposed ideas.   Understand this is a very generic, very vanilla return to play criteria offering an improvement in the current status quo with minimal effort level.   It benefits the athlete, the team, the coach and the training staff. It isn’t created to circumvent policy but to focus on the fact that the sports arena as a whole has a lot of gray areas and a one policy for all is a dangerous concept and often not in the athlete’s best interest.  

    Obviously, any criteria for an injury and return to play is a case by case scenario and should be adapted for each individual case to best match the needs.

    My points…

    We are having the return to play being either negated or done subpar in cases.

    Often it is by the wrong provider based on circumstance and perhaps policy.

    Policy should reflect what is best for the athlete, not be based on the degree of the practitioner.   

    I argue that the Athletic Trainer with help from the coaches is THE BEST qualified people to create and implement return to play criteria, not a note from an ancillary provider.

    Communication helps.   Use the information from the ancillary staff to help make better informed decision in certain cases.   A text or quick call makes a huge difference.

    Return to Play can be fairly simplistic and done in a way that benefits…EVERYONE.